Thursday, August 19, 2021

One way to put things in perspective in Social Studies

Driving to work this morning I heard on the radio that the Dixie Fire in California has now consumed more than 900 square miles of California.  As is often the case with current events, I started to think through K-12 Social Studies and thought where best this story would fit and what would be the best way to help students truly appreciate the size of this fire.  Knowing that the key to teaching numbers in Social Studies is translating the numbers we're trying to teach into a set of numbers that students can visualize or understand.  If you want to give them a sense of the size and scope of something they don't know, you have to find something that they know the size and scope that they do know. 

Any lesson that includes reference to a number of people - ie the population of an ancient city, the size of an army, the casualties in a battle, the number of immigrants, the way to help students understand that number is to come up with a comparison they can understand.  Sports stadiums are quick go-to.  23,000 casualties at the 1862 Battle of Antietam would fill up just about half of Rutgers football stadium (54,000).

So what would be the comparison for size - how can we make students truly appreciate the size of the Dixie fire?  How about the size of Morris county?  Not enough.  How about Morris county and Somerset county together?  Still not enough.  You have to add Union county as well to get even close to an area equal to the size of the Dixie fire.

It took just about five minutes to conduct four searches, and cut and paste about 8 images and screen captures to put this together.



This would work for adults, but not for 4th graders.  Many 4th graders don't know the county they live in, much less the size of it?  But all it takes is a little cognitive elbow grease to come up with something they could relate to.....




The Dixie Fire in California is the size of 23 Walt Disney Worlds put together.  Now,
what do you think?





Sunday, August 1, 2021

The scores are in!

 The summer's mid-July milepost of AP score reports have passed and the autopsy has begun.  It's natural to dig through the data to find the causes behind student test performance, but it's important to recognize that these efforts will probably fail to produce any conclusion of value.  That's never been more true than 2020-2021.  Differences in pass rates between one year and the next can simply be a reflection of the collective personality and performance of each group of students and have nothing to do with teachers or instructional choices.  It's not uncommon for the pass rates to rise and fall within a given percentage.  But this year's shifting schedules, in-person and remote rotations, and a whole host of factors across hundreds of individual teacher, student, and family circumstances make any one guess as to why students scored the way they did as good as any other.

There is one inescapable conclusion that can be safely deduced from the school's College Board test reports - the Social Studies department absolutely dominates it.  We have almost as many passing test scores as the rest of the school combined.  To the extent that AP tests and scores and included in school rankings we can tell the community, "you're welcome".

What's left out of that bean-counting is all that students gain that can't be counted.  Many, many students left classes last year with better writing, talking, and thinking skills, work habits, and dispositions not measured by any assessment.  Many probably think about their lives and the lives of others differently.  And hopefully, they'll tell others about what they've learned in this area, re-gifting what their teachers gave them to make the world a better place.  

For the graphically inclined - this is how well our students did through the most unstable school year anyone can remember. (click to make it larger)