Wednesday, June 30, 2021

History has connections but not closure

One of the real downsides of teaching history is you lose the chance to read as much history as you want while teaching it.  You don't have the time to read, you have to plan, prepare and grade - all of the time.  Any reading you do is limited to what you have to explain to students tomorrow.  It's just one deadline after another, from late August to mid-June.  

But when summer comes and brings with it family vacations, home improvement projects, and a couple other jobs to pay off student loans, you finally have time to read history.  

If you read history long enough, and you're lucky enough to remember just some of what you read, you might just be lucky enough to experience one of those moments when you can find a connection between something you are reading now, and something you remember from a few years ago.  Most often this happens with people and events from completely different time periods, but are spookily familiar.

In his book Nixonland, Richard Perlstein found a 1969 quote from then Governor, Ronald Reagan, who was being asked why police were gassing and shooting at student protestors at the University of California.  He said, "once the dogs of war are unleashed, you must expect that things will happen and that people being human will make mistakes on both sides".  Doesn't that sound just like President Trump's comment about Charlottesville in August of 2017?  "you also had people that were very fine people, on both sides."

Wierd.

Here's another one.  Richard Bond is an associate professor of history at Virginia Wesleyan College who described how he and his students wrestle with the impact of the Protestant Reformation in an interview with the American Historical Association.  

But I do let them talk themselves into confusion. I do let questions hang or comment that there is no short answer or that I do not know enough about the matter to help much. And this leads to the other loss—a sense of closure. We come out of our study of the Reformation with more questions than we had when we began. This is as it should be, I maintain. Studying the Reformation is NOT like learning about derivatives in Calculus. You really do learn what a derivative is. You do not, you cannot, learn how the Reformation changed Western culture. That is the work of a lifetime. And the impact of the Reformation will continue beyond that lifetime. This is difficult for students to accept, as I discuss in the text. It is also hard for us to accept. When we say that we “cover” the Reformation, we mean that we have touched upon all of the topics on a checklist we carry around in our heads. Yes, we explained justification. Yes, we talked about predestination. Yes, we mentioned Luther’s appeal to the German nobility by way of introducing the decisions by princes in Germany, Scandinavia, and England to ally themselves with the cause of reform. Yes, we told our students about the Peasant Revolt of 1525. This is what we actually mean by “cover.” And, if we have gotten to all the items on the list, we have achieved a sort of closure. We have “done” the Reformation.

I have put the matter in these terms precisely because I want you to squirm. I want to emphasize the lack of fit between this sort of closure and actual historical practice. I want to stress its ersatz nature. But I also want to concede the comfort it affords. My students and I deal with all the aspects of the Reformation listed above. But we are not confident we really get what Luther meant by justification. We are confused by the democratic promise implicit in the notion of a priesthood of all believers and how that fits, if at all, with Luther’s notion that princes are “called” by God. We do not know how to take the religious protestations of Henri IV. But we do have some inkling of what a momentous upheaval the Reformation proved.

Putting aside for later the excellent point he is making about the difference between the way history is practiced and the way it is taught, this reminded me of an op-ed piece I read in the Washington Post in October of 2017, the 500th anniversary of Martin Luther's challenge to the Church.  Stanley Hauerwas, a professor in Duke University's Divinity School, and universally regarded expert on the Reformation said essentially the same thing about the impact of the Protestant Reformation - we don't know.  I liked what he was saying so much, I made it into one of the posters we have hanging in the Social Studies office.  

Now that's really weird.






Monday, June 28, 2021

Grade inflation at Chatham

There are at least as many ways to unwind in the summer as there are teachers.  Some people run, others hike, some like reading trashy novels on the beach.  Basically, any slightly repetitive activity requiring just enough cognitive investment to keep from thinking too much will work.  I've known teachers who knit, color, paint, and even one who restored old furniture in his garage for a month straight.  

Unfortunately, I cut, paste and click to unwind.  The key is finding something interesting and important, though without the responsibility of a specific assignment or due date.

So I used something called Piktochart to click, cut, and paste using grade inflation data this morning.  It looks like this unwinding activity is going to result in some real thinking in the fall.
















Wednesday, June 9, 2021

Tristan Harris and Bicycles

 Anyone that spends any time reading history will soon notice how easy it is to make a mistake when talking about the past.  You have to be careful with your language because it's really easy for someone to find evidence that proves what you are saying is inaccurate.

Every statement, every conclusion, every proclamation made about the past can be tested against the evidence.  Especially when those statements include words like

First
Last
Greatest
Biggest 
Never
Always

These superlative statements only need one piece of evidence to prove them wrong, and there's plenty of evidence out there to find.

The digitization of historical evidence that started with the first scans of the founding documents continues to gain speed and size - like the cartoon snowball that gets bigger and bigger and it rolls downhill.  Now we are living in an avalanche of documents, diaries, letters, books, newspapers, magazines, pamphlets, receipts, and recordings. And all of it is searchable.

So if you want to get away with saying - "No one ever said this."  or "This was the very first time that
that happened"  you better do your homework because someone who knows how to search is going to prove you wrong.

Easily.

This movie is a case in point.  Tristan Harris makes this statement about bicycles - and I'm sure most people thought this was true.  It made so much sense.

No one got upset when bicycles showed up. Right? Like, if everyone’s starting to go around on bicycles, no one said, “Oh, my God, we’ve just ruined society. [chuckles] Like, bicycles are affecting people. They’re pulling people away from their kids. They’re ruining the fabric of democracy. People can’t tell what’s true.” Like, we never said any of that stuff about a bicycle.

The problem with Tristan's assertion is that we assume that no one in the past would have thought about bicycles any different than we have.   We think that as long as kids wear helmets, as long as everyone is careful and obeys traffic laws, bicycles are great.  We assume that people in the past thought the same way - why not?

What we should be doing instead is thinking - "Wait a minute",  Tristan just said the words "No One" as in No one got upset when bicycles showed up. Right?

That is a statement that could easily be proven wrong - all it takes is a few minutes of searching in old newspapers.  The nice folks at the Pessimists archive quickly went after this with a 20-second video.



The point of this is not that "hey look - we can prove people wrong all the time".  No one wants to be the person that always says, "Well, actually..."

By going after this statement, searching to see if it is really true - which remember, only took us a few minutes, left us with a much better understanding of the past and a much better understanding of ourselves.  We are not just proving that a number of people in the past were really scared about bicycles and the changes they were making to society, but we are learning that people are often concerned about technology.  We can see it with the invention of the railroad, the telegraph, the telephone, and television - and it is easy to find evidence of us worrying about digital technology.


This makes us more knowledgeable - and leaves us better armed to confront the assertion made in this film - are we wrestling with technology that is fundamentally different than those technologies of the past?